With their meaty texture and mouthwatering flavor, mushrooms are a plant-based cook’s best friend—and we have the recipes to prove it! Here’s everything you need to know about cooking with mushrooms, including how to buy, store, and prepare the most common varieties.
Jump to a Variety
Baby Bella (Cremini)
The Spring 2023 Issue
Our gorgeous “bookazine” features expert tips, inspiration, and 70 fresh and delicious recipes for Spring.
Types of Mushrooms
Here’s a cooking tip that may surprise you: Most mushroom varieties are interchangeable in recipes. That means unlocking the wide variety of flavors and textures mushrooms have to offer is as easy as knowing each type’s distinctive qualities. Photos for all mushroom varieties (except lion’s mane, morel, and chanterelle) are courtesy of the Mushroom Council.
White (Button) Mushrooms
Round, plump, mild-flavored button mushrooms have been a mainstay in kitchens around the world ever since they were first cultivated in France in the 18th century.
Look for creamy white mushrooms with tight caps and no dents or blackish-brown spots.
Rinse well and pat dry. Trim brown ends from stems before slicing or chopping.
Button mushrooms can be used raw in salads; sliced or quartered for soups and sautés; halved for roasted vegetable medleys; strung whole on grilled kebabs; and finely chopped for stuffings, fritters, and veggie burgers. And don’t forget sliced button mushrooms for pizza toppings!
Baby Bella (Cremini)
Tan-capped “baby bellas” belong to the same Agaricus bisporus species as button mushrooms but are harvested later, after they develop their distinctive color and a richer flavor profile. This means they are generally larger than button mushrooms, with a heartier taste and texture.
Choose creminis with smooth, plump caps and dry-looking stems.
Rinse well and pat dry. Trim brown ends from stems before slicing or chopping.
Use buttons and creminis interchangeably, or try a half-and-half combo to maximize the mushroom flavor of a recipe. Creminis’ larger size makes them ideal for stuffing.
Portobellos are the grandaddys of the Agaricus bisporus species. Bigger and firmer than buttons and creminis, portobellos are harvested when they’re mature and have developed a pronounced, earthy flavor.
Select large, flat-capped portobello mushrooms with no dents or black spots. Check the gills to make sure they look dry and firm.
Rinse well, pat dry, then remove the stem and scrape off the black gills underneath the caps. The gills can develop a bitter taste over time.
Grill or roast whole portobellos for delicious burgers, or try them as a meat substitute in stews like a hearty stroganoff.
Ultra-flavorful shiitake mushrooms originated in Asia, where they make their way into soups, stews, and stir-fries.
Choose shiitake mushrooms with firm caps and stems that look tender and fresh, not woody.
Rinse well; pat dry. Remove the tough stems with your fingers or a small knife before using.
To make lip-smacking shiitake bacon, toss 4 cups shiitake mushroom caps with 2 tablespoons reduced-sodium soy sauce and ½ teaspoon smoked paprika; place on a parchment-lined baking sheet and roast at 400˚F for 20 to 25 minutes or until crisp.
Also called hen-of-the-woods, maitake mushrooms grow in big, ruffly masses. Their texture is similar to shiitake mushrooms, but their flavor is more intensely woodsy.
Buy small heads or bunches of maitake mushrooms that show no signs of discoloration. Larger maitake bunches can develop an overly strong flavor.
Pull maitake bunches apart, then rinse well and use a brush to remove any dirt or debris between the flouncy “caps.’ Pat dry.
Use maitake mushrooms in place of shiitakes, or combine with button mushrooms to boost their flavor. Maitake mushrooms are especially good in soups and stews that let their tender-chewy texture shine. You can also pan sear maitake mushrooms in a dry skillet until brown, and serve them as a side dish.
With a mild, lightly sweet flavor, enoki mushrooms grow in long-stemmed bouquets. The bright white fungi have a unique crunch that enhances both cooked and raw dishes.
Enoki mushrooms should be perky and completely white, with no signs of browning or discoloration.
Give the enoki bunch a quick rinse; then trim its base to release the individual long-stemmed mushrooms.
Use raw in salads, sandwiches, spring rolls, and sushi. Or cook in sautés, risottos, and stir-fries.
Oyster mushrooms first gained popularity in Germany during World War I, when they were cultivated during food shortages. Today, they are farmers market favorites, thanks to their complex, umami-rich flavor.
Look for pale, gray-brown oyster mushrooms that have not begun to wilt or sag. Avoid mushrooms that look wet or slimy.
Brush or rinse away any dirt or debris. Trim just the ends, and then slice the fan-shaped caps.
Oyster mushrooms’ velvety texture works especially well in soups, stews, and casseroles.
Massive and meaty, king oyster (or king trumpet) mushrooms have firm caps and stems and a mild, earthy flavor. They are native to the Mediterranean but have been cultivated on a large scale throughout Asia for decades.
Look for caps that are intact and stems that are unblemished. Smaller king oyster mushrooms can be sliced and eaten raw; larger mushrooms are best cooked.
Brush or rinse away any dirt or debris. Trim just the ends. Then slice lengthwise to showcase their shape.
Roast, grill, or air-fry king oyster mushroom slices 3 to 5 minutes per side.
Chanterelle mushrooms have long been considered a delicacy because of their deep, woodsy flavor and stunning golden color. Ever since the sunset-hued fungi were successfully cultivated in the 1990s, they have become increasingly available to home cooks.
Select chanterelles that are bright and firm, with no signs of withering. (The small fungi dry quickly once picked.) Give them a quick sniff; they should have a rich, earthy scent.
Chanterelles have a tendency to cling to dirt and grit. Carefully brush any debris from the caps and stems, or dunk them in a large bowl of water, swirl them around to loosen dirt, and pat dry before using.
High-heat stovetop cooking is best for chanterelles, so use them in sautés and stir-fries.
Wild morel mushrooms are foraged in the spring, which is when you can find the robust-flavored fungi at farmers markets and in specialty stores. Dried morels are easier to come by and can be rehydrated and used like fresh.
Look for fresh morels that are moist and springy with a strong, earthy fragrance.
Soak morels in a large bowl of cool water for 10 minutes to loosen dirt and grit. Gently swish them around in the water. Pat dry before cooking.
Morels are best in dishes that let their flavor play a starring role, such as stews, risottos, and frittatas.
Fluffy and stringy, with a texture that has been compared to crab, lion’s mane mushrooms have a mild taste that lets them take on the flavors of the foods they are cooked with.
Look for fluffy, white mushroom heads with no signs of moisture or discoloration.
Pull the bunch apart into bite-size pieces. Cook them in a dry skillet to remove excess water.
Use dry-sautéed lion’s mane mushrooms as a meat- or seafood-like add-in for plant-based stews and sautés.
These long, brown-capped “bouquet” mushrooms get their name from the beech trees on which they grow. Their flavor is sweet and nutty, and they look spectacular in soups and stews.
Select beech mushrooms that look plump and fresh and are still attached to their base.
Rinse and pat dry. Trim away the base.
Use whole in soups and stews. Add beech mushrooms at the end of cooking time so that they retain their distinctive crunchy texture.
How to Store Fresh Mushrooms
Mushrooms need cool, dry conditions to remain fresh and plump in storage. Keep your purchases in their original packaging, or transfer them to a clean paper bag, which will allow air to circulate and prevent moisture buildup. Store in the crisper drawer of the fridge to avoid exposure to extreme cold.
The best way to freeze mushrooms is to blanch them in boiling water 2 to 4 minutes first. Transfer the blanched mushrooms to a large bowl of ice water to stop cooking, then drain well, and freeze on a parchment-lined baking sheet. Store the frozen mushrooms in freezer containers or resealable plastic bags. You can also skip the blanching step and freeze them raw, but this may affect their color and texture once thawed.
How to Use Dried Mushrooms
Shiitakes, morels, and chanterelles are just a few of the mushrooms that are also available dried. Their flavor is more intense than fresh, and cooking with them is as easy as rehydrating them in boiling water.
To rehydrate dried mushrooms, place them in a heat-safe bowl; then add enough boiling water to cover. Set a plate or lid on top of the bowl to trap in heat and steam, and soak 20 minutes. Drain. (Reserve the soaking liquid for use in vegetable stocks, or as a 1:1 replacement for fish sauce in curry recipes.) Trim away any tough stems, then use in stews, casseroles, rice dishes, and soups, such as our Wild Mushroom Vegan Pho.
Dried mushrooms can also be ground to a powder and used like a seasoning, as they are in this Morel Mushroom and Apple Salad.
How to Tell if Mushrooms Are Bad
Brown spots, dark patches, and blackened edges are all indications that mushrooms are past their prime. All mushrooms are sensitive to excess moisture, extreme temperatures, and long storage times. Avoid or discard mushrooms that look wet, feel sticky or slimy, or emit a strong odor.
Despite their low calorie content, mushrooms boast an impressive nutritional profile. All types are excellent sources of B vitamins, selenium, and copper. Fun fact: Like people, mushrooms can synthesize vitamin D when exposed to sunlight. Commercially produced mushrooms are usually grown in the dark, but wild mushrooms can be rich sources of the vitamin. Some producers now treat button, cremini, and portobellos with UV light to boost their vitamin D content.
Mushroom Recipes from Forks Over Knives
Ready to get cooking? Try one of these delicious, nutritious mushroom recipes from Forks Over Knives.
- Red Lentil Pasta with Silken Leeks and Shiitakes
- Sweet Potato Stuffed Mushrooms
- Grilled Squash and Mushrooms with Fresh Herbs
- Savory Pancakes with Sautéed Mushrooms and Spinach
- Wild Mushroom Vegan Pho
- Sweet Potato and Shiitake Mushroom Dumplings
- Shredded Portobello Open-Face Sandwiches
- Air-Fryer Portobello Burgers with Dressing
- Grilled Mushroom Burgers with Tarragon Crema
- Creamy Vegan Ramen
- Baked Mushroom Polenta Bowls
- Mushroom Stroganoff with Wheatballs
- Best-Ever Beefless Stew
- King Oyster Vegan Cioppino
- Potato-Spinach Casserole with Trumpet Mushrooms
For more guidance in healthy cooking, check out Forks Meal Planner, FOK’s easy weekly meal-planning tool to keep you on a plant-based path. To learn more about a whole-food, plant-based diet, visit our Plant-Based Primer.
This article was originally published on Oct. 1, 2021, and has been updated.