Cathy Fisher is the creator of StraightUpFood.com, a website offering free recipes and information on eating a whole-food, plant-based diet free of salt, oil, and sugar. She is also a cooking instructor, teaching classes at TrueNorth Health Center and the McDougall Program, both in Santa Rosa, CA. Cathy began eating a plant-based diet in 1999, and in 2016 published her first cookbook, Straight Up Food: Delicious and Easy Plant-based Cooking Without Salt, Oil or Sugar. Find her on Instagram and Facebook.see more from this author
easy to make and absolutely delicious. . . the icing isn’t overly sweet and better than buttercream. I would highly recommend.
I made it yesterday to ice a carrote cake, and it was delicious. Instead of using dates [since the cake had plenty of it] I used dry figs. After blending, it went to the fridge for a couple of hours. Turned out delicious with a very soft and silk consistency. Thank you!
Wish I’d read the comments before making this frosting. It’s way too runny. Putting in fridge overnight and hope it helps. Might add some cashew powder to thicken?
Wow! I was so skeptical that this would actually be good or even be frosting like. It’s delicious! The dates give an almost butterscotchy flavor. I heeded the other commenters warnings and was very judicious with adding liquid. I also used oat milk in place of water because it’s the weekend and I’m feeling fancy. Highly recommend.
So good!! First time I made it, I added too much water so it was a little thinner but not a drop went uneaten!
Very creamy and delicious.
I have made this frosting twice and both times it has worked perfectly and tastes amazing on the carrot cake. For those who ended up with it too runny, this is what I did:
– Medjool dates, chopped
– 2 tsps homemade vanilla extract (liquid)
– put all ingredients in Vitamix and barely cover with water. If ingredients are put in a bowl the quantity of water to cover will vary. The amount needed to cover in a Vitamix seems to work.
I’m allergic to dates. What could I use in place of those? Maple syrup maybe?
I just made it with prunes (lower glycemic index) and it is pretty tasty!! 1:1 substitution.
Have you tried (or are you able to eat) dried figs? I’m guessing they would be a similar texture. Worth a try!
Delicious. I have a Vitamix and started with just a little bit of water and kept adding water as-needed Love it!
I followed the recommendations of others and I think my frosting turned out pretty well with some further additions:
1. I poured off nearly all the soaking water before blending.
2. I added a wee bit back in but very little.
3. I added .25 tsp salt
4. I added 2 tbs of cashew butter to help thicken it.
Once refrigerated, the frosting got thicker. I might add a bit less water next time. Otherwise I liked the results!
I used this on the carrot cake and was a bit disappointed. I even added a little salt, vanilla and fresh lime juice to perk up the flavor, but it was just creamy and bland. I also cut way back on the water as others suggested. I think in the future, I will make a glaze with some powdered sweetener and citrus juice.
It does take a while for taste buds to get used to the WFPB diet. I love this frosting.
The Vanilla Bean Frosting came out perfect and was delicious. I would recommend making it. I love that it is sweetened with whole fruit.
We have a cashew allergy in our home. Is there a substitute for the cashews?
Try using mashed Japanese sweet potatoes.
Macadamia nuts work as a sub for cashews. Or sunflower seeds, although the color would change with sunflower seeds.
Making this for the second time. Last time I made it for Easter. My husband and I have been on a whole food plant based diet since he found out he had Graves’ disease. Which he has no more symptoms of now. My daughters wanted a more traditional vegan carrot cake so they made one with sugar and vegan cream cheese from a store. Everyone ended up like this one better. It was excellent!
Cake smelled very good while baking. Cake is moist and loaded with wonderful flavor.
How about raisans ?
This is very tasty. I’m using it on a blueberry cobbler. What I did to make sure it wasn’t too runny is to pour off some of the water into a cup. I started to blend it, checking the consistency. I added a little bit of the water until I got the consistency I desired.
How long is this yummy frosting keep in the refrigerator. And can it be frizen?
How long does this stay good in the frigerator?
How long will this stay fresh in the frigerator?
This is delicious! I read the six comments and got a little concerned it might be watery or too sweet so I made sure I didn’t put too much water, just enough to barely cover the dates and cashews. I put it on the carrot cake recipe and we loved it!
i just made the frosting and it has a very nice texture. I added about half a teaspoon of salt. It balanced out the sweetness and made the taste more complex.
Thank you for the nice recipe 🙂
PS: I would be careful not to add too much water.
I found the frosting very runny and super sweet. I added I think a good cup of cashews afterwards to get the texture like frosting. It’s very delicious but I’d also scale back on the dates and vanilla next batch too. I will probably just activate the cashews separately and set aside the water. Then soak the dates and tip out that water. Then add water as it’s blending so you can set the desired texture.
Can I leave my frosted carrot cake out on my counter? I am worried that the frosting may sink into the cake or become runny.
Delicious and healthy alternative to the butter frosting!
@Tee I have heard that you can substitute the nuts with oats, but I think you should test it before using that for sure 🙂
Any alternative for nut allergies